Musselburgh flood scheme inquiry told project became ‘bugger’s muddle’

Tuesday November 17th 2026

Musselburgh Flood Defences

Artists impression shows walls and embankments which will be built as part of the Musselburgh Flood Protection Scheme

Written by Local Democracy Reporter, Marie Sharp

A public inquiry into a £103million flood protection scheme was told the project became a ‘bugger’s muddle’ after confusion over the involvement of an active travel plan in it.

East Lothian Council’s proposals for the Musselburgh scheme (MFPS) are under scrutiny after Scottish Ministers called them in for scrutiny,

And during a second week of hearings focus turned to the involvement of the Musselburgh Active Travel (MAT)project which had been considered alongside the MFPS for a number of years and was referred to in several master plans and design documents.

The inquiry heard from council representatives that the MAT had been separated from the flood protection scheme before it was notified and would under go its own planning process in the future when it would go out for public consultation.

However objectors raised concerns that the flood protection scheme designs had been drawn up with the MAT in mind and described the late announcement of its separation from the scheme as creating chaos.

Concern, in particular, surrounded route three of the proposed travel plan which covers the coastal route from Fisherrow Harbour in the town to neighbouring Prestongrange and is within the flood protection scheme boundary.

One objector told Scottish Government Reporter Paul Cackette that they were informed the active travel element of the scheme had been removed from the MFPS two days before its outline design went out for public consultation yet details were still in the documents displayed.

And she said many people in the town did not realise their only opportunity to comment on rout three was through the MFPS.

She questioned whether the MAT had been allowed to influence the design in that part of the town telling Mr Cackette: “This whole thing has been a bugger’s muddle. The definition of that is mistakes, blunders, poor organisation that lead to a chaotic situation.”

Concern over whether the MAT had meant decisions were made on the design of the scheme which were not needed were raised by objectors speaking at the inquiry which is set to continue with dates set aside up to March next year.

The public inquiry into the MFPS was sparked after East Lothian Councillors approved the scheme which had received more than 500 unresolved objections, sparking Scottish Government intervention.

The scheme was originally approved at a cost of £8.9million ten years ago but has seen its cost spiral. The flood protection aspect itself is estimated to now cost £53.9m with a further £50m added in to repair seawalls on the edge of the town creating a new cost of £1.3m.

Earlier this year the council was dealt a blow when the Scottish Government set a cap on all flood schemes across the country which would mean the most East Lothian Council could expect is £35.6m – far short of the 80 per cent of national funding needed for the project.

The inquiry is expected to hear evidence on funding at a later session this week which will look at the benefits versus the cost.

Tweet Share on Facebook  
 

Subscribe to the Midlothian View newsletter




Support Midlothian View from as little as £1. It only takes a minute. Thank you.

Comments are closed.