Thursday November 19th 2026

Portobello Beach
Written by Midlothian View Reporter, Liam Eunson
Portobello West beach has been rated “poor” yesterday by the Scottish Environment Protection Agency (SEPA) in its latest bathing water classifications.
Murray slammed the downgrade and the Scottish Government’s approach to water regulation in a Westminster Hall debate in Parliament this afternoon.
Local MP Chris Murray, who met SEPA this morning, says the agency confirmed to him that the primary problem is human sewage, and not gulls or dogs.
The rating follows new SEPA figures, released last week, showing 164 previously unreported sewage spills in Portobello last year, lasting 327 hours.
Murray is running a campaign to tackle sewage at Portobello beach and Fisherrow Sands in Musselburgh. Scottish Water bosses collected more than £250,000 in bonuses last year. Murray asked the First Minister to scrap them, and he said no, so Murray has launched a petition, linked in notes. Over 500 local people have already signed it.
Chris Murray MP explained: “Portobello West beach being rated poor is a shocking wake-up call. It literally stinks.
This beach is loved by local people in Porty, and is Scotland’s most-visited beach, and they should be able to swim there without wondering whether it’s filled with human waste. This summer it was closed with E. coli at ten times the safe limit, and I’ve lost count of the wet wipes and sanitary products I’ve picked up there at litter picks.
“I met with SEPA this morning, and they confirmed the primary problem is human sewage, and not gulls or dogs. This is completely unacceptable, and Scottish Water and the Scottish Government should be ashamed. It is their job to clean up our beach, and they should get to work.
“Dismayingly, Scottish Water bosses collected more than £250,000 in bonuses last year while letting sewage dirty our water. This is a publicly owned company and answerable to Scottish ministers, so why haven’t they stopped these outrageous payments?
“I want to see a clear plan to stop sewage getting into the water. Until Portobello is clean, those bosses’ bonuses should go. Please sign my petition.”
Frazer Lang, Porty Water Collective, added:
“Although saddened by the news of the new classification, we are not surprised. Our continued testing, which carries on after the SEPA bathing water season tests stop, also shows repeatedly high levels of E. coli and faecal matter entering the sea from the Figgate Burn, which can only be coming from sewage outflows or misconnections. We are also discouraged that these consistently elevated levels continue to be blamed on gulls and dogs, which is patently ludicrous, and call for both Scottish Water and SEPA to take more ownership of the situation.”
Sophie Eastwood, Porty Community Energy, said:
“Our community has been concerned about the health of our sea for a long time, and this should be a wake-up call. Porty’s sea is at the heart of our community, used every day by so many, as well as being home to wildlife. We need to see real, urgent action to improve water quality to protect the sea for both people and nature.”
Tweet Share on Facebook