Community councils warn local government reforms could weaken local democracy

Tuesday November 17th 2026

PXL_20251217_101204018-1

The Scottish Parliament at Holyrood, where ministers have proposed major reforms to local government across Scotland.

Written by Local Democracy Reporter, Stuart Sommerville

West Lothian’s community councils have slated plans for local government reform.

The Joint Forum of Community Councils held a special conference last week to debate a response to plans published two months by ministers two months ago.

They fear changes will destroy the grass roots community organisations set up in the 1970s at the first major modern shake up of local government.

One office bearer described the proposals put out for national consultation as adding “insult to injury” for ignoring the views of the Joint Forum in previous consultations .

Donald Stavert, the Treasurer of the Forum told the Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS): “There was an overwhelming view that the Scottish government was completely disregarding everything that people who responded to their Democracy Matters consultation had said over the four years that process took.

“To add insult to injury, they had completely ignored their official report published in March of this year which was ‘Democracy Matters – A route to reform’.

“This looks like a huge centralisation of power taking it further away from communities. A Scottish Minister recently wrote to Community Councils to say the Scottish Government valued the work of Community Councils. That is now in doubt and the ball is now in their court to prove it.”

Scottish ministers have argued that the current 32 local authorities are often “either too big to be local or too small to be strategic”.

Proposals suggest replacing them with six to 10 larger regional authorities for major functions (such as economic development, housing, and transport) paired with 120 to 160 smaller community authorities for local matters (such as householder planning, licensing, and green spaces).

A three – month Consultation Period launched by the Scottish Government is set to end in December.

Community councillors rejected that timescale and unanimously agreed to demand an extension to the December consultation deadline in the paper.

The Forum, which represents the 31 active councils in the county, highlighted the lack of baseline data, missing financial modelling, and chaotic consultation arrangements.

It insisted that the Scottish Government uphold the Democracy Matters Mandate and honour the four years of public evidence gathered by them between 2017 and 2024.

That evidence supported decision-making powers being devolved down to local communities rather than consolidated into 6–10 regional bodies which were mooted it the start of the consultation.

It was also agreed to oppose centralisation of planning and services.

The Forum insisted that strategic planning (including for hyper-scale data centres), local housing, and community services remain directly accountable to local areas, with enforceable statutory duties on public bodies to deliver local community action plans.

Many community councils nationally, and across the county, take a keen interest in planning matters. Some have dedicated planning sub-committees.

The Forum has agreed a formal submission to the Scottish Government and will back a national campaign by the Scottish Forum of Community Councils to build a united national coalition campaign against the centralisation of power.

Tweet Share on Facebook  
 

Subscribe to the Midlothian View newsletter




Support Midlothian View from as little as £1. It only takes a minute. Thank you.

Comments are closed.